Bills running back Marshawn Lynch confirmed on Friday what anyone with a head full of something other than straw knew from the moment word broke that the Porsche SUV he owns was involved in a hit-and-run accident with a woman in the early morning hours of May 31 and Lynch opted to say nothing to anyone about what he knew or didn’t know.
Lynch was driving.
He pleaded guilty on Friday to a traffic violation — failure to exercise due care — and he apologized for the incident.
But Lynch maintains that he didn’t know that he hit the woman in question, apparently because he was distracted by a woman who was dancing in a crosswalk.
“I was not speeding and at no time struck the woman who was dancing and spinning,” Lynch said in a written statement (i.e., a statement he likely didn’t write). “I also never heard, saw or felt anything else that would lead me to believe that I had struck anyone else or anything else at that time.
“I was informed that the police believed that my car had been involved in an accident,” Lynch also said. “At that time, I had no basis to believe that it had been involved in any accident. I was in disbelief over this claim and uncertain how to proceed. I was certain that my car did not strike the dancing pedestrian.
“I am sorry that Ms. Shpeley was struck and injured. Please know that I was completely unaware that my car had made contact with anyone until after the investigation had begun. I would never knowingly leave the scene of an accident and did not do so in this instance.”
Lynch nevertheless was fined the maximum of $100 and stripped of his license by an Administrative Law Judge, who announced that Lynch’s conduct showed “a reckless disregard of human life or property.”
In our view, Lynch’s statement possibly was aimed at providing him with a possible third-party defendant to the civil lawsuit that he surely will be facing. The theory would be that the woman dancing in the street created a hazard, and diverted Lynch’s attention. (There’s a Seinfeld episode on this point. Kind of.)
Still, it doesn’t excuse, in our view, Lynch’s failure to cooperate with police. His image took a major hit as he cowered behind the fifth amendment while police were trying to figure out what was going on. And, in our view, the notion that Lynch didn’t talk to police about the accident because in his mind there was no accident at all is even more flimsy that the attempts at “clarification” this week from the likes of Don Imus and Terry Bradshaw.
[Editor’s note: I previously misread the Buffalo News article, and I concluded that Lynch claimed that the woman he hit was the woman who was “dancing and spinning” in the street. It was, on closer review, a different woman than the woman he claims he didn’t know he hit. We apologize for the error.]
_2.gif)





June 27th, 2008 at 9:13 pm
he left the scene of an accident, and therefore had the time to dry out and clean the vehicle out.
“the cops didnt find anything”. hells bells i think i know why.
he’s a dirtbag.
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: 3 / 5 with 2 rating(s)
June 27th, 2008 at 9:21 pm
“I am sorry that Ms. Shpeley was struck and injured.”
D@mn…he hit her so hard he knocked the vowel right off of her name!
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: 3.5 / 5 with 2 rating(s)
June 27th, 2008 at 9:46 pm
If you hit someone, you should stop and see if they are alright. I don’t care how “small” of an incident that some people are trying to make it into. Driving away from the scene was the wrong choice, and hopefully he will be penalized by Goodell.
drmoyer, NFL players are role models for young people everywhere, therefore they (should) receive more scrutiny when it comes to behavior on and off the field.
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: 3.5 / 5 with 2 rating(s)
June 27th, 2008 at 10:37 pm
It is disgraceful for any lawyer to state that someone “cowered behind the fifth amendment.” What’s next, only guilty people hire lawyers?
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: 5 / 5 with 2 rating(s)
June 27th, 2008 at 11:32 pm
People who say “look at the facts” then attempt to minimze idiotic things that people do just crack me up…
Okay, I will play the game and look at the facts.
Fact 1-he hit another human being with his car.
Fact 2-he fled the scene
Fact 3-he did not cooperate with the police until obtained a layer
FAct 4-he plead the 5th and pit the burden on the state to prove his guilt and when the evidence was piled up against him, his attorney copped a plea.
I’m not saying Maeshawn is a dirtbag: I’m simlpy saying he pulled a dirtbag move.
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: Not yet rated
June 28th, 2008 at 1:59 am
I’m glad some people have taken issue with the “cower behind the 5th amendment” line. It upset me enough that I was actually compelled to register just to comment. You must be a Republican to belittle the Constitution like that. Even besides that, I hate media types of all races tsk tsking and wagging their finger at young men in their early to mid 20’s for the decisions that they make. They just happen to be athletes, so that’s why their mistakes are magnified so much more than those made by almost every other male in his early to mid 20’s. I’m sure that there are a lot of sports media types who have done less than exemplary things. For some reason, though, I just don’t expect to find out about that through the media.
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: Not yet rated
June 28th, 2008 at 8:43 am
maybe all the pot smoke got in the way of his vision
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: Not yet rated
June 28th, 2008 at 9:08 am
Why are people trying to defend him? He hit a woman. This isnt a normal speeding violation. And then it took him weeks to plead guilty? And he’s still not accepting responsibility. Goodell needs to sit him down for 4 games. If any of us hit a woman and drove off you think we would get a $100 ticket?
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: Not yet rated
June 28th, 2008 at 10:12 am
Hey, Mike, what is this, your 10th story on Marshawn Lynch’s traffic accident? I think I’ve seen one story on Nick Kaczur’s drug issues since that story broke–you know, the one where he wore a wire after getting popped for buying 200 Oxycontin pills a week for $8,000 or so. Golly gee, did he have a $400,000 a year habit (do the math) or was there something more there going on? It’s one or the other, by definition, yet we haven’t heard a peep on that one. Seems to me that something like that, that’s so clearly a felony, would rate as a little more important than something that turned out to not even be a misdemeanor, but merely a traffic citation when all was said and done.
Apparently one of the benefits of all the whining Pats’ fans did after Spygate is that it seemed to make reporters gun shy about criticizing the Pats at all anymore, even where they deserve it, like the Kaczur case. Ridiculous…..
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: Not yet rated
June 28th, 2008 at 10:53 am
MF, intrepid sportsblogger and counselor-at-law, says:
“Lynch nevertheless was fined the maximum of $100 and stripped of his license by an Administrative Law Judge …. In our view, Lynch’s statement possibly was aimed at providing him with a possible third-party defendant to the civil lawsuit that he surely will be facing. Still, it doesn’t excuse, in our view, Lynch’s failure to cooperate with police. His image took a major hit as he cowered behind the fifth amendment while police were trying to figure out what was going on.”
I’m shocked - SHOCKED ! - to read that a multi-millionaire black athlete would DARE consult legal counsel after ANY incident involving potentially significant legal and financial ramifications, based merely on minutae such as his potential loss of liberty via incarceration, the NFL Personal Conduct Policy affecting his ability to continue in a highly paid profession, and the almost inevitable third-party civil lawsuits demanding major moola.
Especially for any such incident in a mostly white, blue collar town in upstate NY, way across the country from his California home. And then, horror of horrors, to “cower” behind the US Constitution AND its Bill of Rights! Like he actually HAD RIGHTS or something as a US citizen! I’m SHOCKED, I say!
Oh, wait, wait a minute … there’s some other amendments here, the 13th, 14th, & 15th. Only 145 years old or so, but I believe they provide that black people (those in a “previous coniditon of servitude,” gotta love that Olde American style!) ALSO have rights as citizens, including what is probably THE most basic right in a free society, that against self-incrimination, in the 5th Amendment.
Ya know, I’m not sure, but it think this applies EVEN IF it adversely affects the ability of snarky, bilious bloggers, or, ahh, journalists, to write smug, self-satisfied, snappy jeremiads inveighing against the INJUSTICE of it all.
Hmmmmm, whadaya know? Sorry. Never mind.
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: 5 / 5 with 2 rating(s)
June 28th, 2008 at 11:19 am
Unbelievable that a practicing lawyer writes this dribble. Florio must be in the process of giving up his Law practice cause this severely diminishes his stature as a competent counsel.
To those stating that the guy knew he hit that woman…Seriously? You mean a guy driving an SUV in pouring rain with a ton of distractions around could not miss swiping someone?
You think even if he did hear a thud, as an athlete in Buffalo he’s never had anyone pound on his vehicle as a way to get his attention?
Maybe he did hear sumtin, maybe he thought it was another autograth seeker or just some drunken females looking for trouble and wisely deciding to keep going.
Then here comes accusations of hitting someone….Would you just turn yourself in and start confessing, or would you wait to see what exactly was going on?
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: 5 / 5 with 1 rating(s)
June 28th, 2008 at 11:28 am
As was said
“Fact 1-he hit another human being with his car.
Fact 2-he fled the scene”
Running home after knowing he hit someone shows that he was “high” on something and was trying to clean up.
Bad decision followed by a cover-up. Two crimes.
Using the 5th when falsely accused is one thing. Using the 5th when YOU DID THE CRIME is another. That’s what mob guys do.
Oh, and people guilty or drinking (or smoking) and driving who hit innocent people.
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: 1 / 5 with 1 rating(s)
June 28th, 2008 at 11:58 am
I don’t care what race, creed, or color you are; what religious or sexual preference you have; what your profession is or how much you make doing it, you don’t leave the scene of an accident ESPECIALLY when it involves HITTING A PEDESTRIAN…by the way, that is +/- 500 pounds of man and machine vs. 150-200 pounds of human being.
What is it about normal human instincts do many of you NOT understand? If I even THOUGHT I accidently hit, bumped, nudged, grazed, or even whiffed another human being with my car, I am going to IMMEDIATLY stop and offer assistance. Plain and simply, it is the RIGHT thing to do.
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: Not yet rated
June 28th, 2008 at 12:47 pm
“svnrdr says:
June 28th, 2008 at 11:58 am
I don’t care what race, creed, or color you are; what religious or sexual preference you have; what your profession is or how much you make doing it, you don’t leave the scene of an accident ESPECIALLY when it involves HITTING A PEDESTRIAN…by the way, that is +/- 500 pounds of man and machine vs. 150-200 pounds of human being.
What is it about normal human instincts do many of you NOT understand? If I even THOUGHT I accidently hit, bumped, nudged, grazed, or even whiffed another human being with my car, I am going to IMMEDIATLY stop and offer assistance. Plain and simply, it is the RIGHT thing to do.”
Sure, if you realize you’d hit someone. Lynch claims he didn’t.
Considering that it was 3:30 am, raining, the woman he hit was wearing dark clothes while her friend was drunk dancing across the intersection, drawing attention, Lynch’s contention that his radio was on and the fact that he may have hit her with his mirror (consistent with the police’s description that a piece of the car he hit her with fell off and that she had a small cut–which ain’t likely to be anything on the front of a car) and the fact that eyewitnesses other than the victim’s friends and video seem to show he didn’t brake after crossing the intersection (also consistent with his story) and that he made no effort to either speed away or hide his car, his story can’t be immediately dismissed out of hand as so many here are doing. He may have known he hit her, but for the reasons above he may not.
In addition, FYI, to date no one has claimed to see him drinking alcohol that night, but at least one witness has told the police he was drinking water.
Personally, I wish he’d cooperated with the police sooner, but can understand why a 22 year old in his situation may not–when you’re that young and inexperienced it’s very easy to rely on your lawyers’ advice to stay quiet, even if that’s not the right thing to do.
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: Not yet rated
June 28th, 2008 at 1:20 pm
“Ca_Viking says:
As was said
“Fact 1-he hit another human being with his car.
Fact 2-he fled the scene”
Running home after knowing he hit someone shows that he was “high” on something and was trying to clean up.”
Ca_viking, you are an idiot. Don’t confuse Fleeing with leaving. Nobody can prove that he knowingly did it so it is a moot point. It was an accident that he was unaware of. Nothing more.
and BTW… adults shouldn’t play in the street either!
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: Not yet rated
June 28th, 2008 at 1:37 pm
its kind of a shame that the only posts getting high ratings from other users are either racist posts or posts that blurt out “hes guilty!!!!” without even trying to comprehend the situation.
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: Not yet rated
June 28th, 2008 at 1:43 pm
pleading the fifth is a trick that is used more by the guilty than the innocent… that said if lynch had talked before his lawyer was “in town” and got all the facts he could, then his lawyer would have been an idiot to keep him as a client. People have lawyers b/c they know what can/should be done in certain situations that the general public might not understand, most people are in panic mode at those time & they say/think/do things that they shouldnt, and then they would get rope-a-doped at the police station into giving up false/incriminating evidence/statements.
That said almost everyone can tell when theyve struck anything larger than a rat with their car….. and even with That said, those same people would immediately (impulse action) @least tap their brakes or stop fully so i dont know what the **** to make of this situation b/c certain things just dont add up… unless he was drunk driving, but there are a small handful of “witness’” who saw him either drinking nothing or water but not spirits. So who knows. All i can say is that Goodell is suspicious of many things and he’s good at (or quick to) read between the lines in every situation, so Lynch will face a minimal suspense possiblity or nothing at all, this 4-8 games crap sounds like wishful thinking by bills haters to me b/c it wont happen.
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: Not yet rated
June 28th, 2008 at 8:34 pm
Several thoughts:
1. I’m amazed by the amount of bad grammar. Simply amazed.
2. I can’t wait unitl one of the people who keeps criticizng Marshawn for not talking to the police gets into legal trouble of any sort. Start “cooperating” immediately and see how far that gets you. Rule number 1 when dealing with the police is, “shut up and make them earn it.” Most average citizens don’t know the law. When was the last time you browsed federal statutes, or your local codes and ordinances? You have no clue what law you may be admitting to violating by talking to the police. That’s why any half decent criminal attorney will tell you to say nothing at all.
Florio knows this. He’s just grandstanding. I still love the site Mike. When Florio Jr. gets his license are you going to tell him that if he ever gets pulled over for speeding and the officer asks him, “Do you know why I pulled you over?” precisely to attempt to get him to admit he’s guilty of a crime, are you going to tell him to say, “Yes I do. I was travelling in excess of the speed limit and I am here to cooperate with you fully. If you would kindly hand over a pad and pen I would be happy to document my admission of guilt for you with a signed statement.”? I have a feeling that you’ll do what every good father, let alone attorney, would do and tell him to keep his mouth shut and play dumb.
3. Non-Buffalonians may not realize this but the city of Buffalo just installed 120 cameras, just like the one that caught Lynch, all over the city in the last two years. It’s creepy at best and Orwellian at worst. So far, we have had no significant crimes prevented. In fact, robberies are up in many of the districts where these cameras have been installed. They did manage to almost ruin the Bills season though. Have to love my tax dollars at work.
4. It’s would HAVE not would OF. OF is a preposition. That makes no sense. HAVE is a verb. That makes sense. Please pass this along to your children.
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: Not yet rated
June 29th, 2008 at 4:00 pm
Lynch didn’t see the woman he hit and didn’t know he hit her, thus he couldn’t be guilty of running after hitting. There were numerous factors that prevented him from seeing her (darkness, rain, friend dancing in the street), much less hearing (rain, stereo blaring, sound insulation of the Porsche Cayenne) her doughy body hitting 2 tons of metal and plastic. The punishment fit the crime, since he admitted to being distracted by the friend who was singing and dancing in the rain (obviously) drunk. Reports are that Lynch didn’t even slow down after he hit her, and he parked his car in his driveway instead of hiding it. Case closed, time to move on.
Oh and as has been mentioned, it’s a joke that Florio, allegedly an attorney, would claim that Lynch should have waived his 5th amendment rights. Hopefully any prospective clients will have the good sense to avoid this hack. Stick to your side job, Florio! Not that he’s much better at that, it seems.
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: Not yet rated
June 30th, 2008 at 6:57 pm
I mean, so he bumped a girl, its a bad thing I know. But think about it… he’s the future of the bills franchise right now and we all know and he knows that he can’t afford to get suspended or arrested, it would literally do damage to Buffalo as a city. So he did the sensible thing and realized she wasn’t dead and drove away. So he was probably high and/or drunk as were the other Bills in the car, and the amount of cocaine in the car probably would not have helped their case, but I mean really, the fact of the matter is, is that the girl is alive and well by now and we should all just forget about it and move on. It’s not like he slit his ex-wives’ throat…
(report as inappropriate)
Rating: Not yet rated